Original Article |
|
Corresponding author: Krasimir Kraev ( kkraev@hotmail.com ) © 2024 Petar Uchikov, Nedzhat Ali, Milena Sandeva, Krasimir Kraev, Krasimira Eneva, Bozhidar Hristov, Mariya Kraeva, Elizabet Dzhambazova, Daniela Taneva, Tihomir Tenchev, Angel Uchikov.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Uchikov P, Ali N, Sandeva M, Kraev K, Eneva K, Hristov B, Kraeva M, Dzhambazova E, Taneva D, Tenchev T, Uchikov A (2024) Surgical treatment of pulmonary hydatid disease: a nine-year single-center experience. Folia Medica 66(5): 653-661. https://doi.org/10.3897/folmed.66.e134503
|
Introduction: Hydatidosis is one of the most critical parasitic zoonotic diseases worldwide. Lungs are the second most common site of the disease.
Aim: This study aimed to evaluate the clinical presentation, diagnosis, radiological findings, surgical treatment and post-operative complications of pulmonary hydatid cyst in patients referred to the Second Surgery Clinic at St George University Hospital in Plovdiv, Bulgaria.
Materials and methods: From January 2014 to December 2022, 69 patients were operated on due to pulmonary hydatidosis in the Clinic of Thoracic and Abdominal Surgery at St George University Hospital in Plovdiv, Bulgaria. Demographic data of the patients were collected including clinical symptoms, laboratory studies, radiological findings, location of the lung involvement, and surgical procedures and post-operative complications were recorded.
Results: Pulmonary hydatidosis was confirmed for 69 (46 male and 23 female) patients. The average age of the study group was 31.59±19.49 years. In 29 of the tested patients, specific antibodies of the IgG class to Echinococcus granulosus were positive, and 23 patients showed negative results. The leading symptom was non-productive cough followed by shortness of breath, chest pain, fever, productive cough; rash was reported in one patient. 91.3% of the cases presented with a typical X-ray image and in 8.7% it was atypical. It turned out that 66.7% of patients with an atypical X-ray findings developed complications in the postoperative period. Right lung was affected in 50.7% of the cases. The average size of the echinococcal cyst was 7.43±3.23 cm. Statistical analysis revealed a correlation between the size of the hydatid cyst and the length of the postoperative period. Dissemination in other organs was found in 16 of the patients. No statistically significant differences were reported in the patients with dissemination, regarding the size of the primary hydatid cyst, complications and duration of the postoperative period. The preferred methods of approach were thoracotomy and VATS. The most commonly performed surgical technique was echinococcectomy and capitonnage a modo Delbet followed by two lobectomies and one wedge resection. The mean postoperative period was 7.00±2.81 days. In 12 of the analyzed patients, complications occurred in the postoperative period, and mortality was reported in one patient.
Conclusion: Pulmonary echinococcosis remains a significant health issue in many countries worldwide including Bulgaria. With a prolonged silent period, it is usually diagnosed when clinical symptoms as cough, dyspnea, chest pain and fever start manifesting. Plain chest radiography remains the basic imaging method for initial diagnosis while ELISA test has limited diagnostic accuracy in cases of pulmonary hydatidosis. Irrelevant to surgical approach, Delbet’s capitonnage procedure is associated with good postoperative results and low complication rates.
pulmonary hydatidosis, symptoms, surgical treatment, Delbet’s capitonnage procedure
Echinococcosis is a global epidemic zoonotic disease caused by the larval stages of taeniid cestodes of the genus Echinococcus.[
There are currently several species of the genus Echinococcus recognized[
Naturally, the parasite is transmitted between canids and ungulates in a fecal-oral and predator-prey cycle.[
The aim of this study is to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the clinical presentation, diagnostic approaches, radiological findings, surgical treatments, and post-operative complications in patients diagnosed with pulmonary hydatid cysts at the Second Surgery Clinic of St George University Hospital, Plovdiv, Bulgaria, over a nine-year period from 2014 to 2022.
The study group consisted of patients who underwent surgery for lung diseases, whether diagnosed or undiagnosed, that showed radiologically cystic or heterogeneous opacity from January 2014 to December 2022. They were studied in a retrospective manner. The medical records of these patients underwent a thorough examination. Both preoperative and postoperative characteristics were documented. The imaging methods were performed by radiologists who had a minimum of 10 years of expertise in the field. Each patient underwent preoperative cardiopulmonary evaluation testing, bronchoscopy and abdominal ultrasonography. A chest radiogram and thoracic computed tomography were also conducted. The anti-Echinococcus IgG ELISA test was not regularly conducted for the diagnosis of lung hydatid cyst due to its relatively low sensitivity. However, it was used in cases where hydatid cysts were suspected based on radiological findings.
All patients underwent general anesthesia. Double lumen tube was used in order to avoid the possible spillage of cyst contents into the contra lateral bronchus. We did not perform single-stage surgery on concurrent bilateral intact pulmonary hydatid cysts. Video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) or anterolateral thoracotomy was the preferred method. Although we do not have definite criteria for the choice of the surgical method, thoracotomy was preferred more frequently in lesions bigger than 5 cm and VATS in smaller cysts. After entering the hemithorax, the lung was spared from adhesions of chest wall and then cysts were identified and surrounded by 5% povidone iodine irrigated abdominal lap to prevent seeding of possible ruptured laminated membrane. Pericyst wall was opened and the germinative membrane was delivered and enucleated. Aspiration and evacuation of intact cysts were performed. Bronchial openings were identified using intrapulmonary positive pressure maneuver and irrigation of saline into the cystic cavity and closed by single silk sutures. All of the cavities were obliterated by imbrication sutures from deep to superficial layers using the same suture material. The preferred surgical technique was capitonnage a modo Delbet. Wedge resection or lobectomy operations were performed according to the pathological evaluation and surgical exploration findings. After insertion of one or two chest tubes 24 or 26 French sizes in the pleural cavity, one in the posterolateral and the other in the upper pleural spaces to drain blood and air, the chest was closed using classic approach. Three or four port incisions were used in patients who underwent VATS. First of all, the cyst or cavity was aspirated, and the lesion wall was incised and explored for the germinative membrane. In the absence of germinative membrane, frozen sections were obtained from the cyst cavity contents and studied for intraoperative and definitive pathological diagnosis
Postoperatively, most patients were kept in the surgical department. Those with significant comorbidities were transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU) for the first 24 hours. All patients received prophylactic antibiotic therapy with ceftriaxone at 25-30 mg/kg/day perioperatively. Lung expansion status was monitored with a chest X-ray performed the day after surgery. Chest tubes were removed in patients with expanded lungs and no active air or fluid discharge, typically 3-7 days after surgery, following a mandatory air leak test before drain removal. Decisions for reoperation and a second thoracotomy were made 7-10 days postoperatively, or sooner if a massive air leak was present in the chest tubes, indicating a bronchopleural fistula. The day after chest tube removal, patients in stable condition and able to maintain normal daily activities were discharged and instructed to continue with anthelmintic treatment
To analyze the data, several statistical methods were employed based on the study’s objectives and data characteristics. Descriptive statistics included measures of variation such as standard deviation, minimum, maximum, and range. Frequency analysis was conducted for qualitative variables, presenting absolute and relative frequencies (in percentages), as well as cumulative relative frequencies (in percentages). Graphical representations were also used to illustrate the data.
For hypothesis testing, different methods were applied.
– T-test for two independent samples: This test was used to assess whether there is a statistically significant difference between the means of two independent groups.
– Mann-Whitney U test: Used to compare the mean values between two groups when the distribution is not normal.
– Kruskal-Wallis H test: Applied to compare the average values across three or more groups when the distribution is not normal.
– Chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test: Utilized to explore the relationship between two qualitative variables.
– Median Test: Used to compare the medians between two groups of a quantitative variable.
– Linear regression analysis: it is employed to evaluate potential functional relationships between two or more random variables.
The significance level was set at α=0.05, and the null hypothesis was rejected if the p-value was less than α. SPSS version 23.0 was used for data analysis.
This is a retrospective single-center study focusing on a study group consisting of 69 patients operated on due to lung hydatid disease from January 2014 to December 2022 in the Second Surgery Clinic at St George University Hospital in Plovdiv, Bulgaria (Table
| Characteristic | Value |
| Total number of patients | 69 |
| Average age (±SD) | 31.59±19.49 years |
| Most common age | 12 years |
| Age range most common | 10-19 years (39.1%) |
| Male patients | 46 (66.7%) |
| Female patients | 23 (33.3%) |
| Positive ELISA results | 29 (55.8%) |
| Negative ELISA results | 23 (44.2%) |
| Average size of cyst (±SD) | 7.43±3.23 cm |
| Size range of cyst | 3 cm to 17 cm |
| Complications | 12 (17.4%) |
| Deaths | 1 |
| Duration of postoperative period (± SD) | 7.00±2.81 days |
The average age of the study group was 31.59±19.49 years, with the most common age being 12 years. The majority of patients were in the age range of 10-19 years (39.1%). There were 46 (66.7%) male and 23 (33.3%) female patients, with a male-to-female ratio of 2:1. The average age of females was higher, at 38.04±22.74 years, compared to 28.37±17.00 years for males (p>0.05).
In 52 (75.4%) of the cases, specific antibodies of the IgG class to Echinococcus granulosus were tested using the ELISA method. Out of these, 29 (55.8%) tested positive, and 23 (44.2%) tested negative. No statistically significant correlation was found between the mean size of the hydatid cyst and the results of the ELISA test (p>0.05). The mean size of cysts in ELISA-negative patients was 7.52±3.51 cm, compared to 7.31±3.04 cm in the positive ones, indicating that the cyst size was not related to antibody formation. Of the 69 patients analyzed, 16 (23.2%) had echinococcus dissemination. Notably, 10 (62.5%) of these patients had a positive ELISA result, 3 (18.75%) had a negative result, and 3 (18.75%) were not tested.
The leading symptom in patients with pulmonary hydatid disease was non-productive cough (46, 66.7%), followed by shortness of breath (30, 43.5%), pain (26, 37.7%), fever (22, 31.9%), productive cough (16, 23.2%), and rash (1, 1.4%). Twenty-two (31.9%) had one symptom, 24 (34.8%) had a combination of two symptoms, and 23 (33.3%) had three or more symptoms. There was no statistically significant relationship between the size of the echinococcus cyst and the symptoms manifested. However, a relationship between the number of symptoms and the duration of the postoperative period was demonstrated (p=0.007). The lowest average length of stay was observed in patients with one symptom (mean = 6.14±1.58 days), while the highest was in patients with three or more symptoms (mean = 7.83±3.61 days).
In analyzing the localization of the hydatid cyst, there was an even distribution: 34 (49.3%) cases involved the left lung, and 35 (50.7%) involved the right lung. No significant difference was found in the localization of the cysts across different gender and age groups.
The average size of the echinococcal cyst among the study group was 7.43±3.23 cm, with the smallest size being 3 cm and the largest 17 cm. Linear regression analysis revealed a relationship between the size of the hydatid cyst and the length of the postoperative period (multiple R=0.342) (Fig.
The largest average cyst size was observed in the age group 20-29 years (8.38±2.96 cm), while the smallest was in the age group 30-39 years. A simple T-test revealed a significant difference in mean cyst sizes between these two age groups (p=0.01). No statistically significant difference was found between cyst size and postoperative complications.
Dissemination in other organs was found in 16 (23.2%) of the patients (Table
| Dissemination | N | % |
| Contralateral lung | 11 | 68.75% |
| Liver | 4 | 25% |
| Contralateral lung and liver | 1 | 6.25% |
No statistically significant differences were found in patients with dissemination regarding the size of the primary hydatid cyst, complications, and duration of the postoperative period (Table
| Dissemination cases Х±SD | Cases with no dissemination Х±SD | P | |
| Size of the primary hydatid cyst | 7.19±3.41 | 7.51±3.21 | NS |
| Postoperative period duration | 7.81±2.51 | 6.75±2.88 | NS |
| N (%) | N (%) | ||
| Complications | 5 (31.3%) | 7 (13.2%) | NS |
Three surgical methods were primarily used: thoracotomy with echinococcectomy and capitonnage a modo Delbet (79.7%), VATS with echinococcectomy and capitonnage a modo Delbet (14.5%), and lung resection (5.8%) which included two lobectomies and one wedge resection (Fig.
Linear regression analysis revealed a relationship between the size of the echinococcus cyst and the type of operative approach (multiple R=0.241) (Fig.
Linear regression between the size of the echinococcal cyst and the type of operative approach used.
A statistically significant difference was found regarding size, age, and duration of the postoperative period. A simple T-test showed a significant difference in the average age between the studied groups (p=0.003). The lowest average age was observed in the thoracotomy group with echinococcectomy and capitonnage a modo Delbet (29.98±19.30 years), and the highest in the lung resection group (53.50±19.39 years). The longest postoperative period was observed in the lung resection group (8.25±3.30 days), and the shortest in the VATS group with echinococcectomy and capitonnage a modo Delbet (6.00±1.41 days) (Table
Duration of the postoperative period according to the type of surgical intervention
| Mean | Standard deviation /Х±SD/ | Min. | Max. | P | |
| Thoracotomy Echinococcectomy Capitonnage a modo Delbet | 7.09 | 2.95 | 4 | 19 | 0.03 |
| VATS Echinococcectomy Capitonnage a modo Delbet | 6.00 | 1.41 | 4 | 8 | - |
| Lung resection | 8.25 | 3.30 | 6 | 13 | 0.001 |
Although no statistically significant difference was reported (p>0.05), the thoracotomy group experienced the most complications and the need for rethoracotomy. The mean postoperative period, regardless of the type of surgery performed, was 7.00±2.81 days, with a minimum of 4 days and a maximum of 19 days (Fig.
In 12 (17.4%) of the analyzed patients, complications occurred in the postoperative period, and death was reported in one patient (Table
| Complications | N | % |
| Pleural empyema | 4 | 33.33% |
| Hydropneumothorax | 4 | 33.33% |
| Hemopneumothorax | 1 | 8.33% |
| Pneumonia | 1 | 8.33% |
| Prolonged air-leak | 1 | 8.33% |
| Pneumothorax, encapsulate | 1 | 8.33% |
Three patients with complications required rethoracotomy, and one required re-rethoracotomy. The X-ray image was typical in 63 (91.3%) cases, with no diagnostic difficulties. In 6 (8.7%) cases, it was atypical, requiring a contrast-enhanced CT of the chest for diagnosis. It was found that 66.7% of patients with an atypical X-ray finding developed postoperative complications. A statistically significant relationship was found between an atypical X-ray image and the occurrence of complications (p=0.001; r=0.37). The strength of the relationship between these variables was medium (Cramer’s V=0.401). The probability of developing a postoperative complication in patients with an atypical X-ray image was 13.75 times greater compared to those with a typical X-ray finding (OR=13.75; 95% CI [2.16 – 87.65]).
Surgery is universally recognized as the primary treatment for lung hydatid cysts worldwide. The surgical technique is determined by various aspects including the cyst’s size, whether it is intact or complicated, if it affects one or both sides, whether it is solitary or multiple, and whether it has caused damage to the lung tissue.[
The surgical techniques for treating pulmonary hydatid disease, as described in the literature, encompass various procedures such as complete internal capsule extraction, internal capsule puncture extraction, complete internal and external capsule resection, segmental pulmonary resection, lobectomy, pneumonectomy, and thoracoscopic pulmonary hydatid surgery.[
Different surgical techniques are used for cyst removal. The Ugon enucleation technique is suitable for small cysts, where the space around the lesion is fixed with packs saturated with a scolicidal agent (povidone-iodine or hypertonic saline). An opening is created over the fibrous layer, revealing the white-colored laminated membrane.[
Cystotomy with capitonnage (Barrett method) involves an incision through the lung parenchyma, dissection of the cyst, and positive pressure ventilation. The cavity walls are then closed using non-absorbable sutures. Delbet first described the capitonnage method, involving the folding of the pericyst with circular sutures.[
The Figuera technique uses needle aspiration for cyst extraction. To avoid contamination, towels saturated with povidone-iodine are placed around the cyst, and the fluid is aspirated before the cyst is removed.[
In the literature, the lobectomy rate varies between 0.5% and 45%.[
As the cyst diameter increases, more complications are expected, including prolonged air leakage and atelectasis in large cysts (>10 cm). Intraoperative rupture of cysts can lead to life-threatening anaphylactic shock, with mortality rates between 0% and 23.5%.[
Pulmonary echinococcosis remains a significant health issue in many countries worldwide including Bulgaria. With a prolonged silent period, it is usually diagnosed when clinical symptoms as cough, dyspnea, chest pain and fever start manifesting. Plain chest radiography remains the basic imaging method for initial diagnosis while ELISA test has limited diagnostic accuracy in cases of pulmonary hydatidosis. Irrelevant to surgical approach, Delbet’s capitonnage procedure is associated with good postoperative results and low complication rates.
The authors have no support to report.
The authors have no funding to report.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.